For twenty years the deal with Google was simple. Build a decent website, and Google sends people to it.
That deal is quietly being rewritten.
What's actually happening
Google now answers a lot of questions itself. You search, an AI summary appears at the top, and plenty of people read it and stop there.
The numbers are starting to show it. In 2024, 41% of Google searches led to at least one click. This year it's 32%.
Google's AI Mode goes further. A proper controlled study, with over a thousand real users, found it cut clicks to other websites by 18.8 points. The people using it also said they were less satisfied with their searches. Make of that what you will.
Before anyone panics
Google still sends most of the search traffic most small businesses get. Your site hasn't stopped mattering overnight.
But "rank on Google, get visitors" isn't the whole story any more. And if your website only exists to catch passing traffic, it's going to feel it.
Where AI gets its answers from
When someone asks ChatGPT or Google for "a good electrician near me", the AI has to get that answer from somewhere.
For local businesses, a lot of it comes from your Google Business Profile. One analysis of local-service answers found it was the source 42% of the time. Reviews, opening hours, photos, how you describe what you do. That stuff is now doing a job your homepage used to do.
And it pays to be the one that gets mentioned. Brands cited in Google's AI answers get 35% more clicks than the ones that aren't.
So what's your website for now?
Fewer people will land on it by accident. The ones who do will mostly have already heard of you. They've seen you in an AI answer, a review, a recommendation. They're checking you out.
So your website's job shifts. Less shop window, more closing argument.
It needs to answer the questions people actually have, plainly. It needs to load fast. It needs to make getting in touch easy. And it needs to look like a business someone would trust with their money.
What I'd do this month
Sort your Google Business Profile. Up to date, proper photos, a clear description. Reply to every review, good or bad.
Answer real questions on your site. The ones customers ask you on the phone. In plain English, not marketing speak.
Make it quick and tidy underneath. A fast, well-built site is easier for both people and AI to read.
Stop obsessing over traffic. Watch enquiries instead. Fewer visitors who actually get in touch beats a big number that doesn't.
The honest bit
Nobody knows exactly where this ends up. The data's patchy and Google isn't sharing much.
But the direction is clear. Your website isn't going away. It just has to work harder for the people who do turn up.
So: if someone found you through an AI answer today and clicked through, would your site seal the deal?
Sources
- Search Engine Journal: Google search sends 23% of queries to the open web
- Search Engine Land: Google AI Mode cuts clicks and user satisfaction
- Relevant Audience: AI Mode field experiment, 18.8 points
- Beancount: Getting cited by AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Perplexity
- Searchable: Google AI Mode and brand visibility
- Lilach Bullock