A survey this year found that three out of four web designers see AI as the biggest threat to their business. Bigger than shrinking budgets. Bigger than rising costs.
I get it. But I think they're only half right.
The bit that's true
Some web design work is being replaced. Fast.
AI website builders will knock out a site in minutes for about the price of a takeaway each month. Even Upwork has said low-complexity jobs are being automated faster than they expected.
If your business was installing a template, swapping the colours and dropping in a client's text, that's in trouble. I won't pretend otherwise.
The bit that isn't
The cheap end of web design was never really design. It was assembly.
What AI can't do is the part that actually matters to a business. Working out who the site is for. What it needs to say. What it needs to do. Where it fits with everything else the business runs on.
A lot of what I build these days isn't the website people see. It's the system behind it. Bookings, admin, the stuff that saves someone hours every week. No builder is going to sit down with you and work out what that should be.
And then there's the long game
I still work with clients I first designed for over 20 years ago. I wrote about why that matters.
An AI builder won't remember why you made a decision three years ago. It won't pick up the phone when something breaks. It won't grow the thing with you as the business changes.
That's not nostalgia. That's the job.
When you should use an AI builder
Honestly? Sometimes.
A hobby. A one-page placeholder while you get going. Testing an idea before you spend proper money on it. An AI builder is a perfectly good answer to those, and I'll tell you so if you ask.
The trouble starts when a business that depends on its website treats it like a hobby project.
So who should be worried?
Designers who sell hours and templates. That's the honest answer.
Designers who sell thinking, relationships and results? I'd say we've never been more useful. When everyone can make a website, knowing what it should actually do is the valuable bit.
So here's my question. Is your website something anyone could have made? Or something only your business could have?